South Florida Criminal Attorney
Free Case Evaluation

Broward County Teens Charged With Murder To Assert Stand Your Ground Claim

Two Broward teenagers who have been charged as adults for the crime of second-degree murder will be raising a pre-trial Stand Your Ground claim, asking the court to grant them immunity and dismiss the case.

The two boys, ages 14 and 17, are charged with stabbing a homeless man to death with a pen after a fight over money. The incident allegedly occurred behind a store in Hallandale Beach.

Stand Your Ground is not a trial defense as many believe it to be. It is a claim that is asserted by the defense prior to trial. A Stand Your Ground hearing occurs in front of a judge, not a jury, where the judge must decide whether the Stand Your Ground law applies.

Stand Your Ground is the nickname of a Florida law that permits a person to use lethal force against an attacker in any place where the person has a legal right to be so long as the person believes it is necessary to use lethal force.

If a judge believes that the law applies, the person asserting the claim is granted immunity from prosecution.

Broward County has not been a great jurisdiction in which to ask for Stand Your Ground immunity. In fact, since 2005 - when the law first went into effect - only one Broward County Circuit Court judge has granted a Stand Your Ground motion.

Stand Your Ground is not the end-all, be-all of self-defense. If you lose your Stand Your Ground motion, you may still assert self-defense in your jury trial.

Florida’s self-defense jury instruction is very similar to the Stand Your Ground law when it comes to the use of lethal force.

Eric Matheny is a criminal defense attorney serving Broward County and Miami-Dade County.