Some client stories stay with you. In April 16, 2026, The Law Offices of Eric M. Matheny, P.A. received a powerful reminder of why careful criminal defense work matters long after the original case ends.
“Mr. Eric Matheny handled my criminal sealing so effortlessly. Although there were some minor setbacks during the process, even then, everything was handled so swiftly. My only regret was not finding him sooner. I really wish he was my lawyer from the very beginning of my case. He is worth every penny. Don't hesitate to retain him!”
– Bertha
From “Not Eligible” to a Fresh Opportunity
Bertha came to The Law Offices of Eric M. Matheny, P.A. with a criminal record she hoped to seal. On paper, her situation looked unusual. Attorney Eric Matheny explained:
“This client came to me with a unique issue. She was eligible to have her felony sealed, except she also wasn’t. The charge to which she had entered a no contest plea was not an eligible offense. However, upon a deeper dive, we realized that she had modified her plea so that the charge was changed. She actually wasn’t eligible. It took some effort, but we were able to obtain the necessary court documents and convince FDLE to issue a Certificate of Eligibility.”
This kind of result does not come from a quick glance at a file. It comes from digging into the history of a case, reading every document, and looking for details that others might miss.
A Former Prosecutor’s Eye for Detail
As a former prosecutor, Attorney Matheny knows how charging documents, plea agreements, and court records fit together. In Bertha’s matter, that background supported a strategy that focused on the exact language of her plea and how it affected sealing eligibility.
Instead of accepting “no” at first glance, he reviewed the case history, tracked down prior court paperwork, and presented it to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. That careful approach turned a confusing situation into a clear path forward.
Protecting Rights, Records, & Futures
Criminal defense at The Law Offices of Eric M. Matheny, P.A. does not end when a case closes. Our firm pays close attention to how a record can affect jobs, housing, and future opportunities. Bertha’s testimonial reflects that focus: steady communication, realistic guidance through setbacks, and a commitment to protecting her long-term interests.
If you face criminal charges or have questions about your record, you deserve a defense that takes your future seriously.
To schedule a consultation with The Law Offices of Eric M. Matheny, P.A., call (305) 504-6655 or contact us online today.